Ruby's essay2.docxSecondary Sources-
Themes: Positive feelings, Negative feelings

Secondary source #5:

Ruby's essay2.docx

Notes:


  • Chaunce Depew, prez of NY Central Railroads:"The rays from this beacon lighting this gateway to this continent will welcome the poor and persecuted with the hope oand promise of homes and citizenship. it will teach them that there is room and brotherhood for those who will support our institutions and aid in our development but those who disturb our peace and deubrance our laws are aliens and enemies forever
Secondary Source #6:



  • The 1890s witnessed a sharp decline in arrivals from the peak yearsA young woman arirving from Russia was captured at her first sight of the statue. There she was at the symbol of hope, freedom, and opportunity. She held her torch up high to light the way to a free country. When she was deproted with 500 others, the last thing she saw was the statue of liberty.
    Vocab:
    bigotry:The characterics,stae of mind from a bigot; intolorence
    scurrilous: offensive
    comtemptuous: disrespectful
  • apprehension:misgiving:painful expectation
  • Judge catered to the middle class readers with scurrilous of Irish,Blacks, and Jews depicted the statue as the future emigrant lodging house.
  • More vicious was a cartoon in which Liberty pulls up her robe as garbage ships dump european refuse at her feet. Another one, she was holding her ose while she has a bottle of carbolic acid to kill the stench of the dregs of europe
  • Basically in this document, many offensive things is said about the statue but at the end of the day many peolple still view it as a symbol of hope,peace,liberty,tranquility,freedom,etc


Secondary Source #7:

    • A picture of an immigrant family at Ellis Island looking over the bay brings at the statue conveys a sense of anticipation and apprehension.
    • One Russian immigrant stated"Is this the SOL? So tiny lost in the noise of the harbor and framed against the soaring skyscapers of the Wall Street banks. Was this powerless, tiny figure shrinking before the gigantic bulidings.Is this the SOL we pictured to ourselves.( i guess she wasn't impressed with the statue. She wasn't the only one. Many other people were unmipressed because they expected more than what they got.)
    • Someone called the SOL a great green figure.

  • An italian american publication thought that beneath her cloth, there stood a wicked and insidious.
  • Giuseppe Iannarelli answered to Wilson's question as to what immigarnts think whenthey face the SOL.
  • His answer is, when the italians enter this. They see the SOL.They breathe and think freely at last they have left the strict government and are in the land of the free. Shortly they realize their mistake and become capitalists who owe them soul and body.
  • The statue was a also a symbol of french alliance.
  • The SOL was also a way for Americans to make money for World War I.
Primary Sources
In the document I read, a chinese woamn finds an old article about the fund for the pedestal used beneath the SOL.Chinese Americans feel that the SOL represents liberty for all men in all nations except China. They feel that it is a n insult to have them pay for something that it is not for them. That doesn't include them. Because the French doesnt like the Chinese and it was a present to America from FranCE. They say that they will make a graven image and bow down to it.
My personal reflection and understanding of this is that the SOL doesnt appeal to the chinese because they feel that it doesnt include and when they think of it it is not something they are a part of. They feel neglected and abandoned.

Video, quptes
  • statue was light that was left on at home.
  • when u see it, u feel the importance of being human;special bond
  • u do what u want, when u want it;freeedom
  • Some came to find a way to survive the hadships in their own country
  • some cried . Remembered childhood
  • Never knew what freedom and liberty was until they lost it.
  • One mother didn't expect anything except that she wanted one of her sons to be a governor one day. One of her sons Mario something did become a governor.

Research Questions:


Ruby's essay2.docx